[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Why Questars are so great

Subject: Re: Why Questars are so great
From: Phil Wheeler
Date: Sun, 30 Apr 2006 17:17:31 GMT
Newsgroups: sci.astro.amateur
Brian Tung wrote:
Paul Schlyter wrote:

That should have been phrased as e.g.:  "I lived in Southeast Asia
in 1982, where there was no Internet at that time."

In colloquial English, if one says, "I lived at my grandparents' house
at the time, and *there was no phone service*," one does not mean that
there was no phone service at all anywhere at the time--just at that
house.  It's common usage for native speakers, but not, I suspect, for

I suspect if Davoud were writing a formal paper, he would have been more
precise, in just the fashion you describe.  In any event, it's really
just a trivial matter:

A reasonable reader could easily interpret that as I meant it -- that
there was no Internet in SE Asia.

Assuming that the reader can read the writer's mind has its risks.... :-)

Not in this case, since even if he did have the Internet, it wouldn't
have materially helped Davoud gain the information he needed--he would
have been better off telephoning someone.

Good grief!

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>