|
|
In article <290420061143241187%star@xxxxxxx>, Davoud <star@xxxxxxx> wrote:
> Paul Schlyter wrote:
>> So in 1982, Internet had in fact reached outside North America. But
>> SE Asia most certainly wasn't hooked up to the Internet back in 1982,
>> however it's still false to claim that "there was no Internet" in 1982.
>
> I didn't claim that, though, did I? I said "I lived in Southeast Asia
> in 1982 and there /was/ /no/ /Internet/ ."
That should have been phrased as e.g.: "I lived in Southeast Asia
in 1982, where there was no Internet at that time."
> A reasonable reader could easily interpret that as I meant it -- that
> there was no Internet in SE Asia.
Assuming that the reader can read the writer's mind has its risks.... :-)
> It's like saying "I lived in the Eastern Sahara in 2003 (which I did)
> and there was a water shortage (which there was.") I'll bet you would
> take that to mean that there was a water shortage /in/ /the/ /Eastern/
> /Sahara/ , not that I thought that there was a water shortage
> everywhere on earth.
>
> Davoud
There's never a water shortage everywhere on Earth -- particularly not
in e.g. the oceans.... :-) And it's been that way all the time man has
been on Earth.
However, only some decades ago there indeed was no Internet -- not on
any place on Earth. As opposed to water, Internet is a quite recent
phenomenon on Earth.
Therefore, while the claim "there was a water shortage" is obviously local,
the claim "there was no Internet" (at some time a few decades ago) could be
valid also globally - it depends on how far back that time is.
--
----------------------------------------------------------------
Paul Schlyter, Grev Turegatan 40, SE-114 38 Stockholm, SWEDEN
e-mail: pausch at stockholm dot bostream dot se
WWW: http://stjarnhimlen.se/
|
|