[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Scientist claims to link sahul language 13kya.

Subject: Re: Scientist claims to link sahul language 13kya.
From: prd
Date: Thu, 14 Dec 2006 05:39:10 GMT
Newsgroups: sci.archaeology, sci.lang
In sci.archaeology message  news:1166070862.425433.39100@ by [email protected]  . . . :

> prd wrote:
> The article makes it sound as if these were two simple, homogeneous
> groups. But the unity of Pama-Nyungan is not universally accepted. And
> "Non-Pama-Nyungan" has even more diversity. I don't think you could
> speak of a "unified vocabulary" for either group. Still, if Nick Evans
> doesn't dismiss it out of hand, maybe there's something there. I'll
> look for the original article, and wait to see what John Atkinson
> thinks.

You know my opinion, the resolution between 10 and 15ky is generally
so poor, most theories will end up falling out. 
  But still it is a provocative claim, particularly in lieu of the 
fact they lack any real archaeology, and 13 kya there could have and probably
were a great many languages in that region. 

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>