sci.archaeology
[Top] [All Lists]

Ethnic Bias in Sci.Archaeology

Subject: Ethnic Bias in Sci.Archaeology
From: prd
Date: Thu, 10 Aug 2006 21:23:23 GMT
Newsgroups: sci.archaeology
In sci.archaeology message 
news:44db71f0$0$63442$dbd4d001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx by "Peter Alaca"
<P.Alaca@xxxxxx>  . . . : 

Nice work Peter, lets just see how this group is doing?
[You better put your flame proof trousers on]

Some basic world facts (#s * 1,000,000) sq km and indivdiuals
           Area     Pop   Posts   Pst%/A%* Post%/pop%
Europe(E)   10(8%)  700    55(75)   10    6.4
North Amer  24(18)  550     9(12)   .7    1.3
South Amer  18(13)  450     1(1)    .1     .2
Africa      30(22)  800     3(4)    .2     .3
Asia        45(33) 3000     2(3)    .1     .05
Oceania      8(6%)  500     4(5)    .9     .6
Non-Euro(NE) 125   5300     19      .27    .29   
Bais E:NE                          37:1   22:1

Hey Peter, no reason for shame there, right. Hey
we are doing archaeology! 

FET score, p = 0.00025 versus archaeological news feed. 

 Would you like to see what the baised breakdown is compared to 
real archaeology news? 

Lets take a look at news
Eu 6.5
As 3
NA 6.5
SA 0
Oc 0
Af 3

About the same bias as mine. 


We need a cheer for this group. Rah! Rah! Rah!
'We aren't racist,
 no racist are we, 
they'res not arch_ae_ology, 
cause they're another species'. 

 Even the cats in europe get more archaeology devoted to them than 
other peoples and places. 

Would you like to see what the baised breakdown of
threads is per poster?

PA 22 posts concerning european archaeology
    1* post about european NA archaeology
    1 post about NA archaeology
    6 posts on general topics. 

Bias on topics 34:1 per area and 21:1 per population
Bias on regional topics is 285:1 and 179:1

Here's a FET on comparing you with a actual news sample, below.

TABLE = [ 22 , 2 , 7 , 13 ]
Right  : p-value = 0.00009717327156443482
2-Tail : p-value = 0.00010286025692316755

DW 5* threads concerning eureopean archaeology
   1 post about european/NA archaeology
   1 post about NA archaeology
   3 on general topics. 
* Several posts by doug were asking for translations of swedish or 
italian, and one a repeat of a request for info on the Bosnian 
pyramid, which by and large was a service to the group. 
1 post was on the black sea, half of which is in europe and half of 
which is in asia. 

PD 2 on european
   2 on asian
   1 on oceanian. 

Yes, thats right I am biased also. 
6:1 in favor of european archaeology for regional topics. 
The only two specific threads devoted to asia and 1/2 a thread 
dealing with the black sea (doug) comprise all discussions of the 
asia archaeology by region. But the FET shows what?

Left   : p-value = 0.769960474308298
Right  : p-value = 0.6094861660079183
2-Tail : p-value = 1

My bias is not significant. 

You _think_ these are about archaeology but mostly they are about 
ethnocentric culture within this group. If I were you I would
have kept the threads an enigma. 

European Archaeology
Northern Europe
> ---- Neanderthals and Modern Humans May Have Never Met
> ---- Holocene land-use change at Dallund Sø
> ---- Romani gene found in Anglo-Saxon Grave
> ---- Syphilis in Europe before Columbus
> ---- Fortificated villages
> ---- Varnhem excavation
> ---- Type of graves apart from trad. mounds to look for.
> ---- Viking Longhouse
> ---- Garden under Sandet and Greenland Economy
> ---- Industrial/Fishing Archaeology in North Yorkshire
> ---- Can anyone please translate this from Swedish?
> ---- Dating of Dutch Bronze Age barrows and houses
> ---- Thoughts and questions
> ---- Cat drags in new cairn theory
> ---- Dugouts at Doon
> ---- Highly entertaining dissertation in Swedish
> ---- A Bronze Age Multiple Burial at Wassenaar
> ---- Snorri's coffin?
> ---- North Sea archaeology
> ---- Bridging the two cultures in Brtitish archaeology
> ---- anyone fluent in Italian?
> ---- Waterlevels
> ---- Illerup pictures
> ---- Draw-plates
> ---- Unimaginative Swedes
> ---- Some news about weaponsacrifices
> ---- Underwater City in Scotland
> ---- Frobisher the Fraud
> ---- Staraja Ladoga
> ---- Exotic and sacral finds from Helgo
> ---- Archaeology and Coastal Change in the Netherlands
> ---- Bronze Age in the Baltic
> ---- Modern Times
> ---- YAT
> ---- Rubbish and Archaeology
Central Europe
> ---- Fire ecology N and S of the Alps since the last ice age
> ---- Augst, a Roman town in Switzerland
Southern Europe
> ---- Bosnian 'pyramid', anyone fluent in Italian?
> ---- Tuscan Etruscan link challenged
> ---- European Landscapes
> ---- Greeks and Romans in the Atlantic
> ---- Pre-Roman burial found in Forum
> ---- Ancient skeleton unearthed in Rome
> ---- Persepolis: 6 vs 60 years to build?
> ---- Looks like there are no pyramids in Bosnia
> ---- UNESCO team to probe Bosnia's "ancient pyramid"
> ---- Roman Swords - Development and Influences
> ---- Pitman still arguing for a 6th MBCE Black Sea Flood
> ---- Cross in Ireland with Islamic shahadah on it?
> ---- SUNSTONE, SUN COMPASS
> ---- Europe's First Farmers
> ---- With and without Celts
> ---- Bosnian "pyramide" update
> ---- Attic archaeology
> ---- Digging for cats
North American European
> ---- Back to the Newport Tower
> ---- Norumbega Reconsidered
> ---- Erik the Red never visited Wisconsin


North American Archaeology Indigenous 
> ---- E.P. Grondine - 'MAN AND IMPACT IN THE AMERICAS'
> ---- Faunal changes in Alaska
> ---- Dorset 'longhouses'
> ---- Early Thule housing
> ---- Atlantis AND the Garden of Eden found in Florida!
> ---- Before the white man came? War
> ---- Hunter-Gatherers in a Desert Environment of the
>         Northern Great Basin

South American Archaeology
> ---- Brazilian Stonehenge

Asian
> ---- Lost Culture of the Transbiakal (mine)
> ---- Changing Paradigm for Civilization
> ---- "Lost" Indian-Roman Port "Found?"

African 
> ---- Regarding Egyptian Time Lines
> ---- Restoration of casing stones of great pyramid at giza?
> ---- Ancient Egypt

Austronesia
 Homo sapiens
> ---- Vanuatu archaeology
> ---- No Chinese at Cape Breton
 Homo floresiensis
> ---- Flores Man Debate, Continued
> ---- The divide in the Hobbit sides deepens.
> ---- Old tools shed light on hobbit origins

General
> ---- The pacified past
> ---- On the Significance of Portages
> ---- GOP passes landmark collectors rights resolution
> ---- ARCHAEOLOGY AND DIFFUSION.
> ---- Projection
> ---- Ancient Technology (Speculations)
> ---- Four Corners TV show on Gavin Menzies
> ---- Archaeological Potential of Continental Shelves
> ---- Australian TV show tonight on Gavin Menzies
> ---- Coastal environments and their role in prehistoric
>          migrations
> ---- Significant contributions to archaeology
> ---- Most Notable Archaeologist of the 20th Century
> ---- Treating books as artifacts
> ---- OT: Archaeology Textbook for Sale - Principles of
> ---- Oldest known beads
> ---- Assemblage #9?
> ---- Human Family Tree: Shallow Roots

Arguments about what archaeology is
> ---- Definition of 'Archaeology'
> ---- Can any two people agree on a definition of archaeology?


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>