samba-technical@lists.samba.org
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [SAMBA4] highestCommittedUSN support

Subject: Re: [SAMBA4] highestCommittedUSN support
From: Luke Howard
Date: Mon, 27 Feb 2006 10:33:04 +1100
Hi Tridge,

>unfortunately it would means that on a crash we would lose info. We
>would have records with usnChanged > highestCommittedUSN, which might
>have implications for replication. Having gone to the trouble of
>adding safe transactions and journaling to tdb I don't want to go back :-)

Right, but when you startup you can just search for all entries where
usnChanged > highestCommittedUSN, and then update the in-memory NC
high watermark.

>We already maintain a sequenceNumber that behaves just like
>highestCommittedUSN in @BASEINFO inside ldb, so I'm inclined to just
>use that.

Sure, if you have it, use it -- this is just an optimization.

> > None, although it's possible if you want because the USN namespace is
> > NC-local as far as replication is concerned.
>
>interesting - I assumed it would matter, at the very least for our NT4
>style samsync replication. What do you use for that in XAD ?

In XAD we manage highestCommittedUSN like contextCSN in OpenLDAP, ie.
stored in memory and checkpointed at regular intervals (with recovery
as described above). We actually have a global highestCommittedUSN
but this is more for XAD-specific implementation reasons than trying
to mimic Windows behaviour.

-- Luke

--

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>