opera.general
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Opera cookie settings revisited (was Re: More Opera innovations appr

Subject: Re: Opera cookie settings revisited was Re: More Opera innovations appropriated by Firefox
From: Gerhard Fiedler
Date: Sun, 4 Dec 2005 15:42:20 -0200
Newsgroups: opera.general
Chris Game wrote:

>> Don't try to manage suspect sites with cookies instead of a HOSTS
>> file; remember that there are about 9000 entries in the HOSTS, I
>> wouldn't even think about managing them through the cookies
>> instead.
> 
> I'm surprised you can manage them *at all*. There must be a better
> way!

There is, and it works just about perfectly with Mozilla/Firefox. You just 
would have to use one of these browsers for a little while to understand 
how simple this can be:

When I visit a site that wants to set cookies, a dialog pops up. It allows 
me to choose whether I want to allow those cookies as they are, whether I 
want to allow them as session-only cookies (no matter whether they are 
session cookies or persistent cookies, Mozilla will forget them when 
closed), whether I want to deny the cookie, and whether I want this choice 
to be applied to all future cookies from this server without ever asking me 
again.

In almost all cases I respond with "allow as session-only cookie", as this 
doesn't hurt me and prevents any problems with a site depending on cookies. 
Only for sites I want to remember me I respond with "allow as is". In 
almost all cases I also check to remember this configuration for the 
future. That's it then. And everything I set in that dialog can later be 
modified in the cookie manager, which I almost never have to visit (other 
than with Opera). 

This can be made /so/ simple and effective. I don't understand why Opera 
makes such a complication out of a simple thing. I appreciate the faster 
loading speed Opera has, but that's a bad excuse for a bad user interface. 
And Opera's cookie handling is a schoolbook example for a bad UI. Could 
almost be from Microsoft... :)

Gerhard

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>