On 9 Jun 2010, at 16:11, Randy Whitney wrote:
>> 2. “no proportionate voting”
> Disagree. I would further assert that Naresh is incorrect in his
> understanding of voting in the other RIRs. Within the RIPE community for
> example, many companies represented in voting have multiple votes, some more
> than 20. This means that of the five RIRs, _THREE_ have what is being refer
> to as "proportionate voting". That represents the majority.
Only if they operate multiple registries/NCC memberships. e.g. different
business units (MyCompany UK, MyCompany FR, etc.) may operate different LIRs,
they pay their own sums, they get their own vote. Each LIR though has a single
A single organisation with multiple memberships is very much the exception, not
Sticking my neck out here as a casual observer, hope this is not too rude - but
I think the one member, one vote system is fairest.
apnic-talk mailing list